The Stranger He Chose Over Me

NovelMaster new Completed
现实主义-Realistic重生-Reborn

After his divorce, my brother gave up on women and decided to find himself a “divorce partner.” He posted online saying he had a house, a car, and a steady job. All he wanted was a reliable partner who could take care of the house and his child. Before long, someone left a string of replies. “Hey, I’m a great cook, emotionally stable, and also divorced with a child.” “My ex cheated and made our lives hell. My son and I left with nothing. We have nowhere to go.” “Would you consider taking us in?” Attached was a photo of a plane ticket to our city. I warned my brother to be careful. She could be a scammer. But he brushed me off, his heart overflowing with sympathy. “We’ve both had it rough. If I can help, why wouldn’t I? Besides, what do I have that anyone would want?” But when she used another plane ticket to send them to Thailand, it was too late for him to regret it! My brother was a workaholic. Out of the 365 days in a year, he spent at least 300 working. His ex-wife, Claire, used that as her excuse for cheating. Apparently, she couldn’t stand being lonely. Furious, my brother divorced her and took custody of their son. After the divorce, he wanted our parents to help watch his son whenever they could. But bad luck struck. Mom and Dad were injured in separate car accidents, one right after the other. I suggested hiring a live-in nanny. Instead, my brother jumped on the latest online trend and posted an ad for a “divorce partner.” Thinking of all the scams I’d read about, I urged him to be careful. “Most people keep their money to themselves. You’re offering a house, a car, even school expenses, and you don’t expect her to contribute a cent. You might as well put up a sign saying, ‘Rich idiot here! Come scam me!’” My brother laughed and called me paranoid and out of touch. “If we’re going to form a new kind of family, honesty is the bare minimum. I provide the house and cover basic expenses. She takes care of my son and the chores. That’s fair. Besides, she’s one woman. What could she possibly do to me?” While we were still arguing, his phone started buzzing nonstop. A woman using the screen name “Ethan’s Mom” was posting reply after reply under his ad. “Hey, take a look at my profile!” “I’m easygoing, and I love cooking and housework. I worked in a preschool kitchen for three years, so I’m good with kids.” “I just got divorced and left with nothing but my son. We actually arrived in your city today.” “If it works for you, I can come over whenever you want so you can meet us. All I’m hoping for is a place where my son and I can finally feel safe.” She’d also sent my brother a private message with a photo she’d just taken. The woman wore a plain dress and held the hand of a little boy who looked about seven or eight. They were huddled under an overhang, sheltering from the rain in thin clothes. She was holding a plane ticket to our city. My brother immediately melted. “Her little boy looks about Noah’s age, but he’s so skinny! “She said her ex cheated and made their lives miserable. What a bastard. That poor woman and her son.” He immediately started typing a message with his address and phone number. Alarmed, I grabbed his hand. “Ryan, please just hire a nanny through an agency. At least they run background checks. That’s better than letting some stranger move in. Think about Noah’s safety.” Instead, he rolled his eyes and accused me of having no compassion. “Emma Bennett, I understand mothers better than you do. A mother will do anything for her child. If she weren’t desperate, she wouldn’t have sent such a heartbreaking picture. What’s wrong with helping her? Besides, we’re both divorced. I know what she’s going through.” Nothing I said mattered. He sent the message. About twenty minutes later, someone knocked on the door. The two people from the photograph stood outside, soaking wet. The woman’s name was Vanessa Carter. She wasn’t bad-looking. With a little effort, she could probably be quite attractive. Her son, Ethan Carter, was seven, the same age as Noah. It was winter break, and Noah’s neighborhood friends had all gone away to visit family. He’d been desperate for someone to play with. The moment he saw Ethan, he pulled him inside and started talking nonstop. Seeing Noah with a playmate put a broad smile on my brother’s face. Vanessa quickly dried herself off, then headed into the kitchen to show us what she could do. Judging by her knife skills, she really did know her way around a kitchen. At one point, Ethan accidentally knocked over one of Noah’s favorite toys. Noah threw a screaming fit, but Vanessa somehow managed to coax the little tyrant into laughing. She certainly looked like someone who knew how to handle kids. My brother took a bite of his apple and mocked me. “I told you that you were judging her, but you wouldn’t admit it. With her cooking and the way she handles kids, Vanessa’s better than any live-in nanny. We can speak openly, too. I don’t have to tiptoe around her like I would with hired help.” I still felt uneasy, so I asked Vanessa why she’d come all the way from the northern part of the country to our city in the South. She lowered her eyes and wiped away a tear. “I know it probably sounds ridiculous, traveling so far alone with a child. But I just wanted to get as far away from my ex as possible. I didn’t want my son growing up in that toxic environment and turning out like him.” Vanessa began pouring out her troubles, describing the constant turmoil in her marriage. When my brother heard that her ex had cheated and still terrorized the household, he was livid. He slammed his hand on the table and declared that all cheaters were scum. Then he turned to Vanessa and made her a promise. “Vanessa, you and Ethan can stay here as long as you need. I’ll give you eight hundred dollars a month for household expenses.”I couldn’t stop him. All I could do was watch two strangers move into my brother’s house. Ryan worked in sales and frequently traveled for business. Sure enough, Vanessa and Ethan had barely moved in before he got a message telling him to take a business trip to the next city. Once he left, Noah would be alone in that big house with the Carters. My parents and I were worried sick. They called Ryan and told him to let Noah stay with us for a few days. He snapped, “When I asked you to watch him before, Emma said you’d just had surgery and needed to recover. Now I’ve found someone to help with Noah, and you want to break up our arrangement? Don’t you have anything better to do?” Clearly, he still resented me for refusing to let our parents babysit. But one of them had a broken bone and the other had a hairline fracture. Neither had been in any condition to care for a child. The only reason we could offer now was that I’d taken some vacation days. But my brother was stubborn. He insisted on leaving Noah with Vanessa and Ethan. With no other choice, I started going back and forth between the two houses. After preparing all three meals for my parents, I’d head to Ryan’s place. Vanessa didn’t look surprised to see me. She made me tea, cut up some fruit, and asked me to keep an eye on the boys while they played. She was going to the market for fresh beef so she could make Noah some homemade meatballs. “Vanessa, don’t spend all your time spoiling Noah. Ethan’s so skinny. Make him something good, too.” I pointed to the painfully thin little boy. Vanessa smiled. “Your brother’s the reason we have such a lovely house to live in and a safe bed to sleep in. We can’t be greedy. Having enough to eat is all we ask.” She certainly didn’t sound like someone who was after everything she could get. After she left, I casually questioned Ethan about their life up north. His story mostly matched hers. Noah also told me Ethan had bruises all over his body from his old dad hitting him. He said Vanessa was wonderful to him. She made delicious food and even carved little wooden toys for them to play with. Those were things my brother had never done for him. “Emma, I like Vanessa and Ethan. Please don’t make them leave.” “If they leave our house, they’ll be homeless. That’s so sad.” Noah wrapped his arms around me and begged. But those words brought all my fading suspicions rushing back. If the Carters had already convinced Noah to plead their case, their intentions couldn’t be that simple.Ethan was staring hard at me. I put on an apologetic smile. “I was just being careful before. But now that I see how well you’re all getting along, I feel much better.” “Yay! You’re the best, Emma! Vanessa kept worrying that you’d get Grandma and Grandpa to make them leave.” Noah blurted it out without a second thought. Ethan immediately jumped in. “My mom really likes you and Ryan. She only said that because she doesn’t want to leave you.” Honestly, that was an awfully polished answer for a seven-year-old. Either he was unusually mature, or he and Vanessa had rehearsed their story. I kept smiling and encouraged him to go play with Noah. When Vanessa returned, I deliberately reassured her. I told her I appreciated everything she was doing and trusted her completely. But the moment I left my brother’s house, I pulled out my phone and opened the feed from the hidden camera I’d left in a flowerpot. I’d planted it while Ethan was in the bathroom. It had a clear view of both the living room and the kitchen. On-screen, Vanessa was busy making the homemade beef meatballs. But she added some powder to the bowl she set aside for Noah. Noah happily ate a couple of bites before sleep overcame him and he slumped over the table. The kindness vanished from Vanessa’s face. Her expression turned cold as she popped a meatball into her mouth. “Did you say anything you shouldn’t have while I was gone?” Ethan scrambled to his feet and gave a tiny, frightened shake of his head. Vanessa sneered, grabbed a fold of his skin, and twisted hard. “You’d better not be lying! Behave yourself and help me land this big score, Ethan. Then I’ll let you see your real mother again!” Ethan nodded slightly, his face scrunched in pain. He didn’t dare cry out. So Ethan wasn’t Vanessa’s son. Judging by her viciousness, she was probably the one who’d put those bruises on him. She’d beaten him into submission, then dragged him along to help her scam people. But what exactly did she mean by a “big score”? My brother’s money? Or something else?I was about to record the footage and send it to my brother when he called. He sounded delighted. “Vanessa just told me that you and Mom and Dad have finally accepted them. See? I told you I’m a good judge of character. You were the ones assuming the worst.” He sounded so pleased with himself. I told him outright that Ethan wasn’t Vanessa’s biological son. And that she’d almost certainly come here to scam him. If she wasn’t after his money, she might be after his life. To my disbelief, he started yelling at me. “Emma Bennett, I thought you’d finally learned to treat people with some respect. Instead, you’re making up these vicious lies about Vanessa and Ethan! You’re no sister of mine!” He hung up without giving me a chance to explain. Fine. I’d just send him the video and let him see Vanessa’s true face for himself. But when I opened the app, the camera feed was disconnected. The memory card containing the footage had been removed, too. My brother had probably complained to Vanessa, and she’d discovered the camera. If that was the case, sneaking another camera into the house would be much harder. I was sick with worry. My evidence was gone, and Ryan was so taken with the Carters that he wouldn’t believe a word I said. How was I supposed to prove Vanessa was dangerous? Just then, an unfamiliar number called. I answered and heard Ethan crying on the other end. “Emma, please help me! Vanessa knows you figured out what she’s really doing. She says it’s my fault for not acting well enough, and now she’s going to sell my mom to people who’ll take her organs. I ran away. Please take me to the police!” He sounded so helpless. In the video, Vanessa really had implied that she was holding his mother captive. Remembering how brutally she’d treated him, I couldn’t help feeling sorry for the boy. I asked where he was, then drove over to pick him up. When I saw him, his face was covered in bruises and marks. One eye was badly swollen. “Emma, I’ve been secretly collecting evidence against Vanessa. She traffics women and children. Her gang has my mom. When she saw Ryan’s post, she threatened me until I agreed to help her act out this whole thing.” When he said he had evidence, I asked him for the address without thinking twice. Following his directions, I drove out of the busy city, through the suburbs, and up a steep mountain road. Then we walked for a long time before finally reaching a run-down wooden cabin. Ethan went inside and started searching everywhere, making a huge mess as he overturned tables and chairs. At last, he looked up. “Sorry, Emma. I think I remembered the wrong place.” I froze for a moment, then tried to reassure him. “It’s okay. Your testimony will help, too. Once the police investigate Vanessa, they might be able to follow the trail and rescue your mom.” But Ethan curled his lips into a smile. “What are you talking about, Emma? Vanessa is my real mom!” I knew something was wrong. Ethan had tricked me. Then came a deafening crash. Someone kicked the cabin’s battered door in from outside.Police officers rushed through the doorway. Vanessa followed, her eyes red from crying. Behind her was my furious brother. I stared at them, confused. How had they known I was here? Ryan stormed over and slapped me across the face. “Emma Bennett, have you lost your mind? You kidnapped Ethan just to threaten him and force Vanessa out!” I held my cheek, sick to my stomach. I’d actually believed Ethan was a victim. Now it was clear he was no different from Vanessa. “Ryan, they set me up together. I’m telling you, they’re dangerous. If you don’t get them out of your house, they’ll get you killed!” It was the last warning I would give him. He wouldn’t listen. All he could see was Ethan’s battered face and trembling body. “Ryan, my mom’s had such a hard life. She finally met someone as nice as you, and I finally found a good friend like Noah. Why won’t anyone let us be happy? Why does everyone want us gone?” Tears filled Ethan’s eyes. He looked utterly pitiful. My brother seemed overwhelmed with guilt. He patted Ethan’s shoulder and apologized on my behalf. “Emma’s a heartless lunatic. From now on, she’s no sister of mine. You and your mom can stay in my house. I’m your family now, and no one’s going to make you leave!” Vanessa tearfully protested. “Ryan, she’s your sister. You shouldn’t destroy your relationship over two strangers like us. I’m sure Emma only took Ethan to scare me. She wouldn’t really hurt him.” My brother turned on me in righteous fury. “Scare you? Then what about the injuries on his face? I never knew you were such a monster, Emma. You actually beat a child! People like you belong in jail. Maybe a few days locked up will teach you something!” I was so angry I laughed. “Ryan, did you actually see me hit Ethan?” He ignored me. Instead, he gently wiped Ethan’s tears and asked how he’d gotten hurt. Ethan gave me a frightened glance, then hurriedly waved his hands. “Emma accidentally pushed me, and I fell. It doesn’t hurt at all. Please don’t get her in trouble.” Vanessa agreed that now her son had been found, they should withdraw the report. But my brother insisted they couldn’t. He wanted me punished.

Chapters (5)

第1章

After his divorce, my brother gave up on women and decided to find himself a “divorce partner.” He posted online saying he had a house, a car, and a steady job. All he wanted was a reliable partner who could take care of the house and his child. Before long, someone left a string of replies. “Hey, I’m a great cook, emotionally stable, and also divorced with a child.” “My ex cheated and made our lives hell. My son and I left with nothing. We have nowhere to go.” “Would you consider taking us in?” Attached was a photo of a plane ticket to our city. I warned my brother to be careful. She could be a scammer. But he brushed me off, his heart overflowing with sympathy. “We’ve both had it rough. If I can help, why wouldn’t I? Besides, what do I have that anyone would want?” But when she used another plane ticket to send them to Thailand, it was too late for him to regret it! My brother was a workaholic. Out of the 365 days in a year, he spent at least 300 working. His ex-wife, Claire, used that as her excuse for cheating. Apparently, she couldn’t stand being lonely. Furious, my brother divorced her and took custody of their son. After the divorce, he wanted our parents to help watch his son whenever they could. But bad luck struck. Mom and Dad were injured in separate car accidents, one right after the other. I suggested hiring a live-in nanny. Instead, my brother jumped on the latest online trend and posted an ad for a “divorce partner.” Thinking of all the scams I’d read about, I urged him to be careful. “Most people keep their money to themselves. You’re offering a house, a car, even school expenses, and you don’t expect her to contribute a cent. You might as well put up a sign saying, ‘Rich idiot here! Come scam me!’” My brother laughed and called me paranoid and out of touch. “If we’re going to form a new kind of family, honesty is the bare minimum. I provide the house and cover basic expenses. She takes care of my son and the chores. That’s fair. Besides, she’s one woman. What could she possibly do to me?” While we were still arguing, his phone started buzzing nonstop. A woman using the screen name “Ethan’s Mom” was posting reply after reply under his ad. “Hey, take a look at my profile!” “I’m easygoing, and I love cooking and housework. I worked in a preschool kitchen for three years, so I’m good with kids.” “I just got divorced and left with nothing but my son. We actually arrived in your city today.” “If it works for you, I can come over whenever you want so you can meet us. All I’m hoping for is a place where my son and I can finally feel safe.” She’d also sent my brother a private message with a photo she’d just taken. The woman wore a plain dress and held the hand of a little boy who looked about seven or eight. They were huddled under an overhang, sheltering from the rain in thin clothes. She was holding a plane ticket to our city. My brother immediately melted. “Her little boy looks about Noah’s age, but he’s so skinny! “She said her ex cheated and made their lives miserable. What a bastard. That poor woman and her son.” He immediately started typing a message with his address and phone number. Alarmed, I grabbed his hand. “Ryan, please just hire a nanny through an agency. At least they run background checks. That’s better than letting some stranger move in. Think about Noah’s safety.” Instead, he rolled his eyes and accused me of having no compassion. “Emma Bennett, I understand mothers better than you do. A mother will do anything for her child. If she weren’t desperate, she wouldn’t have sent such a heartbreaking picture. What’s wrong with helping her? Besides, we’re both divorced. I know what she’s going through.” Nothing I said mattered. He sent the message. About twenty minutes later, someone knocked on the door. The two people from the photograph stood outside, soaking wet. The woman’s name was Vanessa Carter. She wasn’t bad-looking. With a little effort, she could probably be quite attractive. Her son, Ethan Carter, was seven, the same age as Noah. It was winter break, and Noah’s neighborhood friends had all gone away to visit family. He’d been desperate for someone to play with. The moment he saw Ethan, he pulled him inside and started talking nonstop. Seeing Noah with a playmate put a broad smile on my brother’s face. Vanessa quickly dried herself off, then headed into the kitchen to show us what she could do. Judging by her knife skills, she really did know her way around a kitchen. At one point, Ethan accidentally knocked over one of Noah’s favorite toys. Noah threw a screaming fit, but Vanessa somehow managed to coax the little tyrant into laughing. She certainly looked like someone who knew how to handle kids. My brother took a bite of his apple and mocked me. “I told you that you were judging her, but you wouldn’t admit it. With her cooking and the way she handles kids, Vanessa’s better than any live-in nanny. We can speak openly, too. I don’t have to tiptoe around her like I would with hired help.” I still felt uneasy, so I asked Vanessa why she’d come all the way from the northern part of the country to our city in the South. She lowered her eyes and wiped away a tear. “I know it probably sounds ridiculous, traveling so far alone with a child. But I just wanted to get as far away from my ex as possible. I didn’t want my son growing up in that toxic environment and turning out like him.” Vanessa began pouring out her troubles, describing the constant turmoil in her marriage. When my brother heard that her ex had cheated and still terrorized the household, he was livid. He slammed his hand on the table and declared that all cheaters were scum. Then he turned to Vanessa and made her a promise. “Vanessa, you and Ethan can stay here as long as you need. I’ll give you eight hundred dollars a month for household expenses.”

第2章

I couldn’t stop him. All I could do was watch two strangers move into my brother’s house. Ryan worked in sales and frequently traveled for business. Sure enough, Vanessa and Ethan had barely moved in before he got a message telling him to take a business trip to the next city. Once he left, Noah would be alone in that big house with the Carters. My parents and I were worried sick. They called Ryan and told him to let Noah stay with us for a few days. He snapped, “When I asked you to watch him before, Emma said you’d just had surgery and needed to recover. Now I’ve found someone to help with Noah, and you want to break up our arrangement? Don’t you have anything better to do?” Clearly, he still resented me for refusing to let our parents babysit. But one of them had a broken bone and the other had a hairline fracture. Neither had been in any condition to care for a child. The only reason we could offer now was that I’d taken some vacation days. But my brother was stubborn. He insisted on leaving Noah with Vanessa and Ethan. With no other choice, I started going back and forth between the two houses. After preparing all three meals for my parents, I’d head to Ryan’s place. Vanessa didn’t look surprised to see me. She made me tea, cut up some fruit, and asked me to keep an eye on the boys while they played. She was going to the market for fresh beef so she could make Noah some homemade meatballs. “Vanessa, don’t spend all your time spoiling Noah. Ethan’s so skinny. Make him something good, too.” I pointed to the painfully thin little boy. Vanessa smiled. “Your brother’s the reason we have such a lovely house to live in and a safe bed to sleep in. We can’t be greedy. Having enough to eat is all we ask.” She certainly didn’t sound like someone who was after everything she could get. After she left, I casually questioned Ethan about their life up north. His story mostly matched hers. Noah also told me Ethan had bruises all over his body from his old dad hitting him. He said Vanessa was wonderful to him. She made delicious food and even carved little wooden toys for them to play with. Those were things my brother had never done for him. “Emma, I like Vanessa and Ethan. Please don’t make them leave.” “If they leave our house, they’ll be homeless. That’s so sad.” Noah wrapped his arms around me and begged. But those words brought all my fading suspicions rushing back. If the Carters had already convinced Noah to plead their case, their intentions couldn’t be that simple.

第3章

Ethan was staring hard at me. I put on an apologetic smile. “I was just being careful before. But now that I see how well you’re all getting along, I feel much better.” “Yay! You’re the best, Emma! Vanessa kept worrying that you’d get Grandma and Grandpa to make them leave.” Noah blurted it out without a second thought. Ethan immediately jumped in. “My mom really likes you and Ryan. She only said that because she doesn’t want to leave you.” Honestly, that was an awfully polished answer for a seven-year-old. Either he was unusually mature, or he and Vanessa had rehearsed their story. I kept smiling and encouraged him to go play with Noah. When Vanessa returned, I deliberately reassured her. I told her I appreciated everything she was doing and trusted her completely. But the moment I left my brother’s house, I pulled out my phone and opened the feed from the hidden camera I’d left in a flowerpot. I’d planted it while Ethan was in the bathroom. It had a clear view of both the living room and the kitchen. On-screen, Vanessa was busy making the homemade beef meatballs. But she added some powder to the bowl she set aside for Noah. Noah happily ate a couple of bites before sleep overcame him and he slumped over the table. The kindness vanished from Vanessa’s face. Her expression turned cold as she popped a meatball into her mouth. “Did you say anything you shouldn’t have while I was gone?” Ethan scrambled to his feet and gave a tiny, frightened shake of his head. Vanessa sneered, grabbed a fold of his skin, and twisted hard. “You’d better not be lying! Behave yourself and help me land this big score, Ethan. Then I’ll let you see your real mother again!” Ethan nodded slightly, his face scrunched in pain. He didn’t dare cry out. So Ethan wasn’t Vanessa’s son. Judging by her viciousness, she was probably the one who’d put those bruises on him. She’d beaten him into submission, then dragged him along to help her scam people. But what exactly did she mean by a “big score”? My brother’s money? Or something else?

第4章

I was about to record the footage and send it to my brother when he called. He sounded delighted. “Vanessa just told me that you and Mom and Dad have finally accepted them. See? I told you I’m a good judge of character. You were the ones assuming the worst.” He sounded so pleased with himself. I told him outright that Ethan wasn’t Vanessa’s biological son. And that she’d almost certainly come here to scam him. If she wasn’t after his money, she might be after his life. To my disbelief, he started yelling at me. “Emma Bennett, I thought you’d finally learned to treat people with some respect. Instead, you’re making up these vicious lies about Vanessa and Ethan! You’re no sister of mine!” He hung up without giving me a chance to explain. Fine. I’d just send him the video and let him see Vanessa’s true face for himself. But when I opened the app, the camera feed was disconnected. The memory card containing the footage had been removed, too. My brother had probably complained to Vanessa, and she’d discovered the camera. If that was the case, sneaking another camera into the house would be much harder. I was sick with worry. My evidence was gone, and Ryan was so taken with the Carters that he wouldn’t believe a word I said. How was I supposed to prove Vanessa was dangerous? Just then, an unfamiliar number called. I answered and heard Ethan crying on the other end. “Emma, please help me! Vanessa knows you figured out what she’s really doing. She says it’s my fault for not acting well enough, and now she’s going to sell my mom to people who’ll take her organs. I ran away. Please take me to the police!” He sounded so helpless. In the video, Vanessa really had implied that she was holding his mother captive. Remembering how brutally she’d treated him, I couldn’t help feeling sorry for the boy. I asked where he was, then drove over to pick him up. When I saw him, his face was covered in bruises and marks. One eye was badly swollen. “Emma, I’ve been secretly collecting evidence against Vanessa. She traffics women and children. Her gang has my mom. When she saw Ryan’s post, she threatened me until I agreed to help her act out this whole thing.” When he said he had evidence, I asked him for the address without thinking twice. Following his directions, I drove out of the busy city, through the suburbs, and up a steep mountain road. Then we walked for a long time before finally reaching a run-down wooden cabin. Ethan went inside and started searching everywhere, making a huge mess as he overturned tables and chairs. At last, he looked up. “Sorry, Emma. I think I remembered the wrong place.” I froze for a moment, then tried to reassure him. “It’s okay. Your testimony will help, too. Once the police investigate Vanessa, they might be able to follow the trail and rescue your mom.” But Ethan curled his lips into a smile. “What are you talking about, Emma? Vanessa is my real mom!” I knew something was wrong. Ethan had tricked me. Then came a deafening crash. Someone kicked the cabin’s battered door in from outside.

第5章

Police officers rushed through the doorway. Vanessa followed, her eyes red from crying. Behind her was my furious brother. I stared at them, confused. How had they known I was here? Ryan stormed over and slapped me across the face. “Emma Bennett, have you lost your mind? You kidnapped Ethan just to threaten him and force Vanessa out!” I held my cheek, sick to my stomach. I’d actually believed Ethan was a victim. Now it was clear he was no different from Vanessa. “Ryan, they set me up together. I’m telling you, they’re dangerous. If you don’t get them out of your house, they’ll get you killed!” It was the last warning I would give him. He wouldn’t listen. All he could see was Ethan’s battered face and trembling body. “Ryan, my mom’s had such a hard life. She finally met someone as nice as you, and I finally found a good friend like Noah. Why won’t anyone let us be happy? Why does everyone want us gone?” Tears filled Ethan’s eyes. He looked utterly pitiful. My brother seemed overwhelmed with guilt. He patted Ethan’s shoulder and apologized on my behalf. “Emma’s a heartless lunatic. From now on, she’s no sister of mine. You and your mom can stay in my house. I’m your family now, and no one’s going to make you leave!” Vanessa tearfully protested. “Ryan, she’s your sister. You shouldn’t destroy your relationship over two strangers like us. I’m sure Emma only took Ethan to scare me. She wouldn’t really hurt him.” My brother turned on me in righteous fury. “Scare you? Then what about the injuries on his face? I never knew you were such a monster, Emma. You actually beat a child! People like you belong in jail. Maybe a few days locked up will teach you something!” I was so angry I laughed. “Ryan, did you actually see me hit Ethan?” He ignored me. Instead, he gently wiped Ethan’s tears and asked how he’d gotten hurt. Ethan gave me a frightened glance, then hurriedly waved his hands. “Emma accidentally pushed me, and I fell. It doesn’t hurt at all. Please don’t get her in trouble.” Vanessa agreed that now her son had been found, they should withdraw the report. But my brother insisted they couldn’t. He wanted me punished.