Loading promotion info...
Breaking Free from the Toxic Trio
My roommate, Chloe Bennett, claimed she had a condition that made her cry uncontrollably. You couldn't criticize her, much less raise your voice at her. Once she started crying, she supposedly couldn't stop. I had no interest in upsetting her. Neither did our other roommates. We all tiptoed around her. Until she posted on our campus confessions page, accusing all three of us of bullying her. Condemnation flooded in, and our academic advisor called us in for separate meetings. My university merit scholarship was revoked. My parents got dragged into it. Our other two roommates sank into depression under the relentless online harassment. One took a leave of absence. The other dropped out. Meanwhile, Chloe built her fame and fortune on our ruined lives and even secured a funded place in graduate school. Then all three of us were sent back in time. Uncontrollable tears? False accusations of bullying? Fine. We'd give her exactly what she accused us of. If she wanted evil, we could play that game. "Emma, aren't you on cleaning duty today? The bathroom's still dirty. Could you mop it again? We'll get another warning if the resident assistant sees it like that!" The pain of being killed by a car hadn't completely faded when I heard that familiar question. That voice was familiar, too. Familiar enough to hate. My eyes flew open. I sucked in a breath like someone dragged out of deep water and stared straight at Chloe. She stood in front of me in a short white skirt, her hair tied in a low ponytail. The picture of innocence, she gazed at me with wide, guileless eyes. Chloe Bennett. My fists clenched. Even I could hear the cold fury in my voice. "Why should I mop it again? It's your turn today. You said you had something to do this morning, so I helped you out. You're free now. Shouldn't you do it yourself?" Chloe froze. Clearly, she hadn't expected this attitude from someone who was usually so easygoing. Her eyes reddened. "Emma, why are you being so mean?" She instinctively turned to our other two roommates, Sophie Carter and Lily Brooks. "Sophie, Lily, did I say something wrong? Why is Emma snapping at me?" Her voice took on a helpless little tremble. Normally, softhearted Sophie and Lily would already be comforting her, offering to mop, and quietly telling me to let it go. But now, I saw disbelief fill both their eyes. Then they turned toward Chloe together, their expressions slowly flooding with hatred. Was this a dream? One last dream born of everything I couldn't let go? After Chloe accused us of bullying her, Sophie, Lily, and I were plunged into a living hell of online abuse. Bullying had become an especially sensitive subject in recent years. Right before graduation, Chloe suddenly posted a long story on the campus confessions page, claiming she'd endured relentless bullying in our room. She sobbed on livestream, acting forgiving and brave while showing off a fake diagnosis of depression. Her admirers, unsuspecting viewers, and the university administration were furious. The university merit scholarship I'd worked so hard for was suspended while the accusations were supposedly being reviewed. Someone smashed the windows of my parents' store, splashed red paint over it, and wrote, "BULLIES AND THEIR FAMILIES SHOULD DIE." Even grocery shopping meant sneers and nasty comments from other shoppers. Sophie's boyfriend of three years broke up with her on the spot, publicly distancing himself from her. He posted on social media, "I never knew you were such a disgusting person!" Then he started showering Chloe with attention, claiming he was making up for what Sophie had done. No matter how Sophie explained, nobody believed her. Even her parents coldly threw her out. "Our family has nothing to do with a bully like you anymore. Show your face here again, and see what happens. It's bad enough that you've ruined your own future. You're not ruining your brother's, too!" Then our academic advisor summoned us and "gently" suggested that we apologize and withdraw. He said he would refer us to student conduct if we refused, and warned that a disciplinary hold could delay graduation. We shouldn't damage the university's reputation, he said. Sophie couldn't take it. She broke down, took a leave of absence, and disappeared. Lily's fate was just as awful. She was beautiful - not in Chloe's fragile, innocent way, but striking and glamorous. With even a little effort, she could have looked like someone born to grace a red carpet. But she came from a remote rural town. She'd always been timid, apologetic, and afraid to draw attention. Forget makeup or dressing up. Even wearing a long dress embarrassed her. She thought it made her stand out too much. Once she was accused of bullying Chloe, Chloe's admirers seemed to think they'd found a righteous excuse. They dragged Lily off a deserted path into a patch of woods. Those scumbags assaulted her, photographed her, insulted her, and beat her, all while congratulating themselves on being heroes. They shouted things like: "You deserve this! This is what you did to Chloe, right? You should fucking die!" "What goes around comes around! Now you know what being bullied feels like!" "Slut! Dirty bitch! This is all you're good for!" How did I know? Because those monsters passed the video around for entertainment. People who knew nothing about what had happened watched it and cheered, calling it justice and saying the bullies had finally gotten what they deserved. Lily was shattered. Severely depressed, she couldn't even speak up to defend herself. She dropped out. The three of us had been close, but I could do nothing as they left one after another. I was drowning, too. All I could do was keep going to class under the weight of everyone's hatred and keep posting rebuttals. Then, dazed and exhausted on my way home, I stepped into the path of a car and died. After that terrible pain, I was back in our room. Back before any of it had happened. Was this a dream? I stared at Chloe with hatred and secretly pinched myself hard. The pain was real. This wasn't a dream. Maybe all three of us had come back.A second later, Lily - the softest of us all - spoke in an icy voice. "Chloe, it's your turn to clean. Emma helped you out of kindness, and now you're making it her problem? "What, are your arms and legs broken?" Chloe went still. Even the tears she'd been working up seemed to retreat. Her eyes widened. "Lily! What the hell are you saying?" The harsh words slipped out before she could stop them. Realizing her mistake, Chloe instantly switched back to looking fragile and blinked at Sophie, who hadn't said a word. "Sophie, what has gotten into them today? Even if they are upset, they cannot take it out on me. I-" "Chloe, if you've got time for all this, you've got time to mop the bathroom. It was your job in the first place. Instead of thanking Emma, you're standing here whining. Do you actually want another warning from the resident assistant?" Sophie cut her off before the tears could fall. The three of us exchanged a look, then left the room without another glance at Chloe, who stood there caught between crying and not crying. We found a quiet corner away from the dorm, where no one could overhear us. None of us spoke first. Our last lives - if that was what we could call them - were still painfully vivid. None of us had moved past what happened. Going back in time didn't erase the wounds. After two minutes, I took a deep breath and broke the silence. "Whether this is a dream or something else, I'm not living through that again." Lily nodded. I thought she might cry, but her eyes weren't even red. They held only numbness and a hard, cold resolve. Sophie looked the same. She pulled out her phone and called a contact saved as "Babe." She put it on speaker and started recording. Before she could speak, the man on the other end launched into her. "Sophie! Do you have any idea how out of line you are? Why are you always bullying your roommate? You know Chloe's a year below me in my department. Do you know how awkward you're making this for me? Are you doing it on purpose?" Lily and I exchanged a look. Of course. Sophie's backstabbing boyfriend. From the sound of it, those two had been involved for a while. What decent boyfriend would take someone else's side and berate his girlfriend like that? What a piece of trash. Sophie's eyes showed nothing. She'd given up on this loser in her last life. Why would he have any power over her now? "We're done, Ryan." His lecture stopped abruptly. When he spoke again, he sounded stunned. "What? Sophie, have you lost your mind? You're breaking up with me because I pointed out what you did wrong? Can you be any more petty? Women, I swear!" Sophie didn't respond. She just kept recording until Ryan, who was used to being worshipped in their relationship, got embarrassed and furious enough to start swearing at her. Then she said casually, "I know about you and Chloe." Ryan fell silent. After a long moment, he replied without a trace of shame, "There's nothing going on between us. She's just a friend from my department. Is that why you're so nasty to her? You're fucking sick!" "You sent me a photo from your hotel room. Chloe's reflection was in the mirror. Still want to tell me there's nothing going on?" "You - Sophie, don't you dare! I've still got those pictures of you. Think carefully before you do something stupid. So what if I like Chloe? She's gentler than you, prettier than you, kinder than you! She's better than you in every way. Maybe ask yourself why I picked her instead of you!" Listening to that manipulative scumbag threaten her with intimate photos made both Lily and me furious. My breathing grew heavy, and Lily gently patted my back. Sophie stayed expressionless. Once she had the recording, she gave a silent, mocking laugh, hung up, and blocked him. She hadn't wavered once. Her face gave nothing away. I looked at her, worried, and started to speak. She raised a hand to stop me. Then Sophie turned toward us. Something about her had changed, but her eyes were bright. "I figured it out. Family like that, a boyfriend like that - I don't need any of them. I feel lighter without them." "Sophie." "You think I'm pretending? I died last time because I still expected something from them. I went to the ocean. The water was so cold. At the very end, I wanted to live, but I'd gone too far. I couldn't find my way back to shore. This time, I'm not letting them trap me. Nothing gets to trap me anymore." She spoke softly, each word clear. I looked at her. "She says we bullied her, right? Then let's give her what she wants."Maybe our changed behavior set off a butterfly effect. That very afternoon, our hypocrite of an advisor called us in ahead of schedule. "The three of you are deliberately excluding Chloe?" In his office, our advisor glared at us and slammed a folder down on his desk. If we'd still been the sheltered girls we were in our last lives, instinctively afraid of authority and respectful of our teachers, his fury would have terrified us. But this time, we knew better. "Mr. Collins, where did you hear that rumor?" Lily asked calmly. Her striking looks were even more commanding now, framed by her cool, unbothered manner. She was no longer the timid Lily who'd spent her last life hoping nobody would notice her. Our advisor was an ordinary, balding middle-aged man. As he looked at Lily, a flicker of fascination crossed his eyes. It took him several seconds to recover. "Who says it's a rumor? Clearly, none of you care about staying at this university. You'll each write a ten-thousand-word statement of remorse and publish it as an apology to Chloe. It had better be sincere. Don't make me refer you to student conduct." I noticed Sophie secretly recording on her phone. After a moment's thought, I said, "Mr. Collins, if we'd done that, of course we'd apologize. But what if you've accepted one side of the story and falsely accused us? What happens then?" Martin Collins immediately snapped as though I'd hit a nerve. "How could it be false? Chloe was sobbing and shaking! She was terrified! She told me everything. You insult her every day, force her to do all your cleaning, and shut her out. How could that be made up?" "What evidence do you have?" I asked earnestly. Martin faltered, then grew angrier. "Evidence? She's told me what happened, and you're still denying it? Your character is appalling!" "So," I interrupted, expressionless, "all your accusations are based entirely on Chloe's account. You haven't checked a single thing she said. And now you're using anger and intimidation to label us bullies, while threatening our education if we refuse to apologize?" Perhaps I'd laid it out too smoothly. Martin's face darkened. He started to speak, but Lily cut in. She deliberately softened her voice, playing good cop to my bad cop. "Mr. Collins, Emma doesn't mean any disrespect. She's upset because she's been falsely accused. There must be some misunderstanding." "A misunderstanding? There's no misunderstanding! I know what kind of girl Chloe is. She would never lie!" Lily gave him the faintest smile. "In that case, since we won't accept being falsely accused either, let's refer this to the administration and have them investigate."